
Explore Will and Jack’s choices with RedLines Myths, compare game versions and three Personal Boundaries sets, and try discussion formats without points.
This material is for informational and educational purposes only and is not medical, psychological, or psychotherapeutic advice. If you are experiencing an acute psychological condition or need professional support, please contact a doctor, psychologist, psychotherapist, or crisis service.
Jack Sparrow tells Will Turner that his father was a pirate. Will resists: the father he remembers was a good man. The two statements do not fit his understanding. Before examining the new information, he defends the familiar image.
This episode forms training round 00 of RedLines Myths: The Hero’s Three Paths. It is a teaching story adapted from a film, followed by mythological stories in the game. You do not need to remember the whole film. Start with what Will hears and the belief it challenges.
Here I examine a particular process: new information conflicts with an important belief; the need to restore certainty then narrows the available choices. My educational framework compares holding on to a familiar rule, automatically doing its opposite, and examining the situation again. The story can support a conversation, another perspective or a professional discussion. Participants agree on its purpose and depth.

RedLines Myths cards and discussion materials. MriyaRun photo.
What Will is trying to preserve
The word “pirate” challenges more than a historical detail. It touches the image of his father that Will has lived with. If a good man cannot be a pirate, Will must either reject Jack’s account or reconsider what he thought was settled. Reconsideration takes time: he needs to tolerate uncertainty and ask which actions lie behind the label.
Arguing can offer immediate relief. Will can defend his father, question the messenger and briefly restore the familiar picture. But rejecting the uncomfortable information also closes off a chance to learn more.
Separate the event, its interpretation and the next action. Jack calls the father a pirate. Will treats goodness and piracy as incompatible. He can then deny, ask, check the source or end the conversation. A strong feeling does not decide which action must follow.
Expert experience: the question behind the training round
The author’s instruction asks, in translation from Ukrainian: “Why is it hard for Will to believe his father was a pirate?” One answer expresses the rule: “If his father was a good man, he could not have been a pirate.”
Source: training round 00, section 13 of Dmytro Telushko’s instruction. These translated extracts identify the subject of the discussion: the connection between information and a character’s belief, rather than a hidden personality trait for players to guess.

Dmytro Telushko holding his book «Казкотерапія. Тінь». Photo provided by the author.
Running the Will and Jack training round
Read the situation and question before revealing the explanation. Give participants time to develop their own interpretation. The author’s training material offers four options, translated here:
- A. Anyone who knew my father is obliged to help me.
- B. If my father was a good man, he could not have been a pirate.
- C. If someone knows my name, they are telling the truth.
- D. If I am better with a sword, I can command the ship.
Each person can choose an answer or pass. Ask for one detail supporting the choice. This separates something present in the account from something a participant has added.
Then reveal the explanation. The key is B: Will struggles to reconcile his father’s goodness with the label “pirate”. This training round uses no points; it introduces the sequence of discussion.
Four answers and three paths serve different purposes. A letter records an interpretation of the situation. The paths explore what the character could do next and the cost of each direction.
Will’s three paths
Within this game’s model, the script path repeats an inflexible rule, while the counter-script path automatically does the opposite. These are working meanings in the material, not every meaning of counterscript in transactional analysis. An autonomous choice considers facts, wishes and available actions.
| Comparison axis | Preserve the familiar rule | Automatically do the opposite | Examine the situation and choose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Inner demand | Keep a flawless image of the father | Reject everything if the image was inaccurate | Learn about the father without letting his story determine one’s own life |
| Immediate result | Certainty returns | Contradictory information no longer needs to be integrated | Specific questions become possible |
| Cost | Some facts remain inaccessible | Memories and individual actions are discarded together | Time and tolerance of doubt are needed |
| Next action | Deny the news | Stop exploring anything connected with the father | Ask what Jack knows directly and assess the details |
The second branch is an imagined alternative for comparison, not a claim about the film’s continuation. Rejecting an old image completely can still be an inflexible rule.
The third path does not require Will to trust Jack immediately. Information about his father and trust in this particular speaker are separate questions. One accurate statement does not settle every later proposal.
Jack also has a need and a limit to his authority
Jack needs a companion to continue his journey. His information comes with an interest of his own. A person can know a true fact and also want our help. Before agreeing, it is useful to understand the proposal, our role and what happens if we refuse.
In the author’s teaching model, travelling to Tortuga illustrates cooperation. Jack can propose a route and roles; Will can evaluate the offer. An agreement does not become voluntary merely because one person is more persuasive or has greater control of the situation.
Expert experience: another person’s right to refuse
The instruction states, translated from Ukrainian: “If Will refuses, Jack will have to find another way to continue the journey.”
Source: the author’s training-round analysis, instruction page 24. For me, the important point is that respecting another person’s choice can change our plans. Winning an argument and obtaining agreement to cooperate are different outcomes.
When a participant disagrees with the key
A different answer gives the group something to investigate. Which detail did the participant notice? What assumption did they make? Does the account support it?
“Show us what you are basing that on” keeps the discussion open. “You are defensive, so you cannot see the right answer” assigns an untested psychological process to the participant. It turns the key into pressure.
Expert experience: the author’s explanation can be questioned
“The author’s answer can also be discussed and challenged with reference to the text.” This is a translation from Dmytro Telushko’s instruction, page 6.
The key offers an authored reading; its grounds remain open to examination. Identifying missing information is also a useful result. A group can name what needs checking instead of inventing a fact.
Midas, Icarus and Theseus: three other questions about decisions
Midas: what happens to other needs when I get what I want? The golden gift fulfils his wish, but bread becomes gold too. A choice assessed by a single measure can overlook food, sleep, relationships or time. Ask what was left out of the calculation.
Icarus: are the conditions still the same? An initially successful flight does not establish what will happen at another height. The story separates “it worked before” from “does the same approach work now?” Workload, rest and new responsibilities can change the conditions of an everyday choice.
Theseus: how will I return after completing the main task? Ariadne’s thread supports the exit from the labyrinth. Preparing for the challenge without preparing for the return leaves something important unresolved. Ask what help will be needed after reaching the goal.
These are examples of the author’s discussion approach. Check the relevant edition’s contents to establish which stories belong to the base set or an additional collection.

RedLines Myths cards: different stories for exploring decisions. MriyaRun photo.
The base set and additional cards are separate purchases
The current RedLines Myths base-set description lists 50 double-sided cards, an instruction, voting cards and a bag. The physical game is in Ukrainian and intended for adults.
The Myths expansion contains 50 additional stories, numbered 51–100, and a bag. It does not include a printed instruction or voting cards. Its product page describes it as an expansion for voting and discussion with any RedLines game, not a standalone game. Examples drawn from extended materials do not mean that all 100 stories are included in the base purchase.
Training round 00 is discussed here from the author’s instruction. Check how it is supplied in the chosen edition, rather than assuming a separate physical card is included. Use the current rules for player numbers and duration.

Sorting newly received RedLines Myths cards. Photo provided by the author.

RedLines Myths additional cards, purchased separately. MriyaRun photo.
Different RedLines versions ask different questions
Emotional Detective focuses on interaction: behaviour, its impact, pressure and conflicting expectations. EQ brings attention to a character’s feelings and responses through body, thought and action. Myths examines a decision rule and alternative directions. Personal Boundaries applies questions of consent, agreements and responsibility to particular areas of life.
The subjects overlap. Their difference is the main question organising the conversation.
| RedLines version | Main question | What participants examine | Choose it when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Emotional Detective | What is happening between people? | Behaviour, possible motives, pressure and impact | You want a broader discussion of interaction |
| EQ | What is the character experiencing? | Feelings, thoughts, bodily responses and actions | You want to develop emotional vocabulary |
| Myths | Which rule guides the decision? | Repetition, automatic opposition and an examined choice | You want to compare alternative actions |
| Personal Boundaries | What is agreed, permitted and each person’s responsibility? | Consent, requests, refusal and consequences | You want to explore a particular relationship setting |
Shared discussion does not mean identical contents or rules. Choose the main task first and check the specific set’s description.

Emotional Detective cards held in the hands. MriyaRun photo.

RedLines EQ set with its instruction. MriyaRun photo.
Personal Boundaries has three separate parts
The three parts organise situations by life setting. According to the author’s instruction they can be used separately or combined. Each current product description lists 50 situations in Ukrainian.
| Part | Setting | Questions to explore | Useful focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| Family and Home | Household and family relationships | Shared space, help, privacy and obligations | Distinguishing a request from an assumed duty |
| Close Relationships | Intimacy and personal closeness | Consent, contact, distance and expectations | Making room for different wishes |
| Work | Professional relationships | Roles, workload, authority and responsibility | Clarifying an agreement and a possible refusal |
The common subject is a boundary in interaction. The context changes what a request, refusal or consequence can mean. Refusing a colleague and refusing someone who controls your employment do not carry the same practical risks.

RedLines Personal Boundaries: Family and Home. MriyaRun photo.

RedLines Personal Boundaries: Close Relationships. MriyaRun photo.

RedLines Personal Boundaries: Work. MriyaRun photo.
One everyday episode through four lenses
Consider an illustrative situation, not a claimed quotation from a particular card: during a meeting, a colleague interrupts someone’s explanation with a joke. Several people laugh and the speaker falls silent.
The Detective lens examines the interaction. Who could finish a thought? What did the interruption change? What would happen if the speaker asked for it to stop? We can name an impact without first establishing a hidden motive.
The EQ lens explores experience: anger, embarrassment or confusion, and what the person themselves notices in body and thought. The joker’s emotion also needs checking; a joke alone does not establish envy or fear.
The Myths lens asks which rule guides the next action. “I must laugh along to belong” leaves little room for dissatisfaction. “I will never explain anything again” closes off other options. A specific response could be: “I’ll finish the explanation, and then we can return to the joke.” Other circumstances may call for a pause, private conversation or support.
The Work Boundaries lens examines roles and agreements. Who is responsible for the meeting? How can interruptions be stopped? Hierarchy matters: a manager’s remark and a peer’s remark can affect the freedom to disagree differently.
You do not need every set to begin. Decide what kind of conversation would be useful now.
Another perspective, a teaching story and a shared experience
A card can be worthwhile without a winner. One participant notices an agreement, another a dependency, and a third an overlooked possibility. Understanding another person’s reasoning does not require accepting their conclusion.
Sometimes a teaching example is enough. What if the character asked a question first? How does unequal power affect the choice? What would we need to know before calling an action a boundary violation?
A conversational or professional session can use an agreed format without points. This is an adaptation of the material; the competitive rules remain in the relevant instruction. The meeting’s purpose determines which elements to use.
Using a story in a therapy session
A therapist and client can agree to explore one story. Begin with the character: what happened, what explanation arose and what stood out. The therapist may then invite the client to consider anything familiar. The client can make a personal connection, stay with the story or choose another subject.
Will’s story could open a conversation about maintaining a relationship after learning something difficult about someone. The client decides whether it relates to their experience. The key does not diagnose them, and the therapist’s task is not to lead them to the author’s letter.
Professional use depends on an agreed purpose, the client’s situation and the practitioner’s competence. Consent, confidentiality and the right to stop remain central. A card can supplement therapeutic work; it is not a separately validated treatment. The BACP Ethical Framework provides general professional guidance, not an endorsement of this game.
Exploring group dynamics through a shared story
There are two subjects: what happened to the character and how the group discusses it now. Someone answers first; someone waits for a majority; someone asks to return to the text; another supports a view before articulating their own.
These are observations of a particular interaction, not fixed personality roles. Familiarity, status, tiredness, facilitation and the meeting format also affect participation. Agree openly if the group wants to examine its process.
- Does everyone have time to finish a thought?
- After disagreement, do people ask, withdraw, joke or rush to a vote?
- Can someone change their answer after new information?
- Does the group turn to the text, facilitator, majority or most confident speaker?
- Can a person pass and remain a full participant?
A facilitator might ask: “When another interpretation appeared, we quickly voted. Had everyone understood its argument?” This offers a shared inquiry rather than covert assessment.

Emotional Detective cards for comparing interpretations. MriyaRun photo.
Ten ways to use RedLines
These are possible adaptations, not compulsory modes supplied with every set.
- An evening with friends: compare stories without requiring personal disclosure.
- Emotional literacy education: distinguish feeling, thought, impulse and action with EQ.
- A boundaries workshop: explore consent, agreements and responsibility in one setting.
- Individual therapy: with consent, use a story to explore meanings and experience.
- A therapy group: within its agreement, examine responses and current interaction.
- Facilitator or psychologist training: practise clarification and checking hypotheses.
- Supervision or peer learning: compare interventions using fiction, without substituting it for facts of a real case.
- A couple’s conversation: discuss characters, then make a mutually agreed personal request; do not use a card as proof against a partner.
- A team workshop: explore responsibility and disagreement, not hidden employee testing.
- Written reflection: record an interpretation before opening the explanation, then notice what changed.
A useful outcome may be a better question, a clearer meaning, an alternative explanation or an action someone wants to try.

RedLines EQ cards and instruction for discussing emotions. MriyaRun photo.
What is the secret of RedLines?
For me, its value is making reasoning visible. A person chooses an interpretation, identifies a detail, hears another view and returns to the story. There is space between first certainty and a final conclusion.
The shared story gives the conversation a third point of attention. Participants can discuss a character without immediately recounting their own conflict. A facilitator asks what happened, checks the grounds for an interpretation and explores consequences. Personal disclosure remains a choice.
The other part is a possible next step. Naming a feeling leads to considering how to respond. Recognising pressure leads to formulating a boundary. Recognising an inflexible rule leads to trying another action under particular conditions.
I therefore suggest looking beyond agreement with the answer key: did the reasoning become more specific, did participants distinguish fact from assumption, and did another action become visible? These are discussion-process observations, not invented evidence of clinical effectiveness.
A game, image cards or writing: compare the task
Sometimes you need a shared story. Sometimes an image helps name a subject. Sometimes private writing is the useful next step. Compare the work you want to do rather than ranking products as treatments.
| Format | Starting point | What the person does | When it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| RedLines Myths | Story, question and a character’s decision | Explains an answer and compares three paths | A shared conversation about choice |
| Dream. Desire. Imagine image cards | An image and personal association | Describes and clarifies its personal meaning | A subject is difficult to name directly |
| EQ journal | An event and emotional response | Names feelings and records observations | Exploring one’s response after a conversation |
| CBT SHIFT | A situation and automatic thought | Checks an interpretation and considers an action | Examining a particular prediction in writing |
These are suggested uses, not a ranking of treatment outcomes. An ordinary notebook is also enough; buying several tools is unnecessary.
Taking something away from a round
After Will’s story, notice what affected you: revising an image of someone, checking a source or negotiating cooperation. Start with an ordinary episode rather than searching for a major life parallel.
A colleague might propose a project with a recommendation from someone you trust. Write down what is known about the proposal and what remains unclear. The recommendation can matter without replacing all other information.
Five lines are enough: event; first interpretation; feeling; impulse; what I will check before deciding. The next step could be a question, agreement, refusal or pause.
Frequently asked questions
Which RedLines version should I choose?
Choose Detective for interaction, EQ for emotions, Myths for alternative decisions, or the relevant Personal Boundaries part for consent and responsibility in a particular setting.
Are points compulsory?
No. An agreed educational, conversational or therapeutic adaptation can explore a story without scoring.
Are the additional cards included in the base set?
No. They are a separate purchase. Check the contents of the base set and the selected expansion.
- MriyaRun: Journals, MAC Cards and Self-Reflection
- Self-Discovery
- Will, Jack and the hero’s three paths: exploring choices with RedLines Myths
